瓦利日记2022年5月17日:战争电影让我厌烦

2022-05-17 8,936 0

 

中文翻译:

战争电影让我厌烦,它们让我厌烦。因为它们离现实很远,真实的战争比电影要有趣得多,但也要可怕得多。

以电影《拯救大兵瑞恩》为例。

看这部电影时,人们的印象是诺曼底登陆是一个真正的地狱。然而,影片展示的是最糟糕的情况——奥马哈海滩,奥马哈被恰如其分地称为 "血腥的奥马哈",因为那里是德军防线最坚固的地方,其他海滩并没有那么血腥。有些海滩甚至是 "几近平静",哪里的德军的防御设施此前已被大炮和航空兵基本摧毁。

还应了解的是,诺曼底登陆战实际上包括了好几波突击。而电影《拯救大兵瑞恩》中展示的是最糟糕的海滩上最糟糕的一次突击(首次)。

此外,盟军的空军还有效地阻止了德国人的援军抵达海滩。如果说德军在海滩上的表现令人失望,那只是因为他们无法把他们最好的部队送到那里去! 因此,最激烈的战斗往往不是发生在海滩上,而是在登陆后的内陆地区。因此,参加D-Day(表示发起作战的那天)的大多数士兵都没有在海滩上开过枪! 这些士兵中的许多人肯定以为接下来的事情也会如此轻松!然而,许多人却死了。同样,战争,真正的战争,是如此具有欺骗性和卑鄙。

我很快就会告诉你这部电影中其他不全面的地方,或许你将永远不会再以同样的方式观看战争电影。

原文:WAR MOVIES BORE ME

War movies bore me. They bore me, because they are far from reality. Real war is so much more interesting, but also so much more terrible.

Take, for example, the movie Saving Private Ryan…

Watching the film, one has the impression that the Normandy landings were a real hell. However, the film shows the worst of the worst: Omaha beach. Omaha is aptly nicknamed "Bloody Omaha" because the German defenses there were still in good condition. The other beaches weren't as bloody. Some beaches were even "almost quiet": the German defenses had previously been largely destroyed by artillery and aviation.

It should also be remembered that the Landing included several assault waves. The film Saving Private Ryan therefore shows the worst beach, and the worst assault wave (the first).

In addition, the Allied aircraft prevented the Germans from bringing reinforcements to the beaches. If the Germans were disappointing on the beaches, it was simply because they were unable to bring their best troops there! The most violent fighting therefore often did not take place on the beaches, but inland, after the landings. The majority of the soldiers who took part in the D-Day therefore did not fire any shots on the beaches! Many of these soldiers then surely thought that what followed was going to be easy! Many were, however, to die. Again, war, the real one, is so deceptive and underhanded.

I will soon tell you about other distorted aspects of this film. You will never watch war movies the same way again.

相关文章

瓦利日记序
瓦利日记2022年5月29日:训练进行时
瓦利日记2022年5月28日:志愿军战士与俄罗斯坦克的对决
瓦利日记2022年5月27日:虚假的信息战争
瓦利日记2022年5月26日:《Legion》杂志上的Wali
瓦利日记2022年5月24日:俄国人已经无力回天了

发布评论